|
R I V E R P O I N T |
|
R E P O R T |
Turbulence Elicits Prudent
Response
Several
times in the last year, we have written about our concerns with the risk level
of the stock market. Some of these risks
include the risk inherent in the high degree of leverage found in hedge funds,
the risk of using esoteric investment products, or the risk stemming from the
sub-prime mortgage market. It appears
that these risks have combined to cause investors concern about the direction
of the market. It is for these reasons
that we are rebalancing our clients’ portfolios by shifting 5% from
equities to bonds and cash.
In
fact, over the past year, we have developed strategies to mitigate these risks
in a few different ways. Earlier in the
year, we took profits in the form of equity gains and reallocated the proceeds
into bonds and cash. We also have
avoided investing in companies heavily exposed to the sub-prime mortgage
market. And we have continued to advise
clients against the use of hedge funds. This has turned out to be prudent
advice given the number of high-profile hedge fund losses in 2007.
For
most of the year, the sub-prime mortgage meltdown had been relegated to a
relatively small segment of the overall mortgage market. However, recent volatility in the stock
market reflects concerns that fallout from the sub-prime sector is becoming
more widespread. Because it will take
time for this situation to play out, we believe it is prudent to reduce our
clients’ current equity allocation for the second time this year.
Yet,
as we have reiterated throughout 2007, underlying fundamentals of both the
economy and the stock market appear to be in good shape. The global economy is expanding, corporate
profit growth is still positive, and market valuations continue to be
reasonable on a historical basis. In a
recent issue of Barron’s, Ned
Davis Research pointed out that over the last 35 years, the S&P 500 Index
has returned an average of 11% per annum when the index’s price/earnings
(P/E) ratio drops below 18. (Currently, the S&P 500’s P/E ratio stands at 16.6.)
The
uncertainty surrounding how far and how broadly the effects of the sub-prime
crisis will spread is the major concern we have right now. It is also the main catalyst behind our
decision to reduce equity exposure.
While we have alerted our clients to our concerns about sub-prime
mortgages in the past, the long reach of this crisis has surprised many
investors. Not only has the crunch
driven many mortgage lending firms into bankruptcy in 2007, but now tangential
effects are taking a real toll on other participants in the marketplace. Several highly leveraged hedge funds have
suffered massive losses as their sub-prime related holdings have deteriorated in
value. This price collapse has led to
margin calls by the hedge funds’ lenders, which causes “distress
selling” and drives the security prices even lower, resulting in even
greater losses at the funds (A website, www.hf-implode.com, tracking such failures
has even sprung up.) Falling security
prices have increased the risk premium demanded by lenders and buyers of
corporate debt, making it more difficult for companies, private equity firms
and leveraged buy-out funds to raise capital to complete their deals. This lack of new deals has, in turn, caused
fixed income trading to slow to a crawl, making it difficult for yet other
firms to sell securities needed to repay short-term obligations.
No
one is certain when this cycle will stop or who will end up bearing the brunt
of the fallout. One thing is certain,
however, our constant advice against the use of hedge funds by our clients has
proven to be sage advice. Not only are hedge
fund fees exorbitant, but the amount of leverage employed also puts them in
danger of realizing spectacular losses as well as potentially realizing
spectacular gains. For example, earlier
in the year two hedge funds managed by Bear Stearns ran into significant
problems due to the heavy leverage they utilized. As of March 31, 2007, the two funds combined
held over $1.5 billion in capital that was leveraged to more than $20 billion
in assets (over thirteen times their capital).
The intent of such leverage was to magnify small gains into much larger
ones. In this case, though, the large
debt burden had the opposite effect, magnifying reasonable losses and
generating calamitous results. It should
be pointed out that similar degrees of leverage are probably being used by a
large number of hedge funds. The
relatively lax regulatory environment surrounding hedge funds makes it
difficult, if not impossible, to tell which hedge funds are dangerously
levered. Our investment strategy and
research team is continually monitoring this hedge fund imbroglio to determine
if any other changes to client portfolios should be made.
The
recent actions of central bankers around the world have eased the short-term
liquidity concerns in the credit markets. The Federal Reserve Bank of the United
States, along with the European Central Bank and others, have injected billions
of dollars into the financial system in order to induce the flow of capital
into the credit markets. Also, the
Federal Reserve’s recent move to cut the discount rate (the rate the Fed
charges banks to borrow money) by half a percent sent a strong signal to the
markets that it will take swift action when necessary. We also believe that the odds of a federal
funds rate cut (the rate at which banks loan fed funds to other private
institutions) on or possibly before its September 18th meeting have
increased, especially if the sub-prime market continues to deteriorate and
credit markets remain stagnant. To keep
things in perspective, despite the recent pullback in the equity market, this
has been one of the longest running bull markets in history without a 10%
correction. At this point, we would consider the recent pullback in the equity
market as natural. Even accounting for
the pullback, the S&P 500 Index is still positive on a year-to-date basis
and over the last four years has generated an average annual gain of
approximately 12%.
Going
forward, we will continue to monitor the situation closely. As the uncertainty in the marketplace plays
itself out, there will almost certainly be chances to purchase shares of high-quality
companies at attractive prices. In this
way, times like these can provide an opportunity to add some fresh and exciting
prospects to our clients’ investment portfolios.
|
Market Summary |
08/31/07 |
YTD Price Change |
|
Dow Jones Industrial
Average |
13,357 |
7.2% |
|
Nasdaq Composite |
2,596 |
7.5% |
|
Standard &
Poor’s 500 Index |
1,473 |
3.9% |
For information about RiverPoint
Capital Management or to view our report archive visit us at www.riverpointcm.com.